Rate the signature above you!

[Porsche-AG]

Creativity: 5 (Lots of people use car sigs, but you've presented it in a fairly unique way.)
Appearance: 5 (Looks decent, but kind of messy IMO.)
Detail: 7 (I can see that there's a fair amount of detail put into the sig, and the border isn't repetitive.)

Overall: 6 (Pretty good sig overall)

[RobinZ]

Creativity: 6 (not too creative)
Appearance: 10 (looks amazing and clean, and i love ferraris )
Detail: 9 (nice even fade-out and nice details on the name )

Overall: 9 (Absolutely amazing altogether. Doesn't need creativity as the details and appearance says it all )


Plz rate this one:



It's a sig i made for Ferrari4yoface. but because the height limit is so small, it sucks as a sig on this forum . Click for larger image.

It's the first thing i've ever made on PhotoShop

[xHaZxMaTx]

Yeeg, stop spamming your signature (if you can even call it a sig).

Anyway, snoop, it's a fox. Also, I didn't make the sig.

Please don't rate my sig, rate whoever's sig posted before me.

[RobinZ]

hehe

[snoopdogg879]

@xhazxmatx tell me before i rate it

@robinz thats not a sig its a ficken pic of a ferarri that u erased the front liciens plate a wrot ferarri 4 yo face in it and did bevel and embos to it to make it look real which it doesnt

if u want it made into a sig, just tell me and i will be happy to make it into one but u have to wait until next wednesday until i can make it because i dont have photoshop where im at right now and i dont get back till wednesday

sorry for going off topic

[RobinZ]

... there were other things that i had to edit and change you know... and it is my FIRST thing i've made in PS, and the "ferrari4yoface" isn't supposed to look like it's part of the car or a license plate or whatever.

[snoopdogg879]

OFF TOPIC: okay so u put a border around it too

well tell what u did then if there was more editing done

sorry to be kinda mean
ill make a sig for out of it for u
but i cant do it for a week
so ill stop being mean

[RobinZ]

why'd you look it up to find the orig. image???


i'm still learning the features of PS right now, so i just added the border, and added an adjustment layer to fix up some color issues (the original pic was a lot more yellow than i liked)

[Porsche-AG]

K guys, I think this off-topicness is just turning into an MSN conversation. If you want to continue mutually arguing, please do it in the privacy of your own private messages

[RobinZ]

lol sry

[ahmad0410]

C'mon guys?!? 7 post without even rating the previous sig AT ALL!?!?

@RobinZ:

Creativity: 2 (o.0)
Appearance: 2

OVERALL: 2

Sorry dude, I can't make myself to consider that as a signature.

[Jopuma]

Creativiy: 3-Poor (It's a car and there are quite a few sigs of cars that I've seen. Angle isn't very creative either)
Appearance: 9-Outrageous (The overall construction, aesthetics, and feel of the sig are extremely well done. The slight shine, very faint scanlines, and the beautiful size of the sig make it incredibly well done.)
Detail: 5-Average (Not very detailed but it still holds enough to keep you looking at it for quite some time.)

Overall: 5.7-Above Average (Not bad. )

[BrontoX]

Creativity: 8 (not many have Browser sigs)
Aesthetics: 5 (Not very good looking in my opinion but still Average)
Detail: 7 (Detailed.)

Overall: 6.66

[ImJ]

Creativity : First good console pic i've seen ( 8 )
Appearance : Need more attractive colours well i know it matches the PS3 but its kinda dull ( 5 )
Detail : ( 7 )


6.88

[SP4RCO]

Great console

8 points

[ahmad0410]

Great console

8 points

Err?

@ImJ:

Creativity: 6
Appearance: 7

Overall: 6.5

[Cipher]

creativity=9.8
Appearance=7.6
Overall=8.3

I like your sig lots
I did not make me sig so no one rate mines

[Jopuma]

I did not make me sig so no one rate mines

When you rate people rate the sig above them. So yours will be rated.

[BrontoX]

Cipher:

Creativity: 3 - Everyone has car sigs.
Aesthetics: 7 - Looks great but the scan line opacity could be set lower or set them on overlay.
Detail: 5 - Detail is a bit low it looks like low res pics were used but that may be the scanlines doing that

[S2000_Skyline12]

Creativity: 8 (PS3 sig, first one i've seen here)
Appearance: 7 (It's nice but it's kinda bland)
Difficulty: 6

Overall:7 (It's nice and all, just that the B/W thing isn't too attractive to me here)

[ImJ]

Creativity : 6 ( first phone sig i ever seen which looks like a PC Keyboard or maybe a laptop )
Appearance : 7 ( Colours are really attractive and stands out alot )
Difficulty :4 ( Aint that hard using brushes and blabbing it all around the phone )

[ImJ]

Hmmm can i rate my own sig, btw why is this topic dead :/

[S2000_Skyline12]

Creativity: 5 (Cars, car forum...)
Appearance: 8 (Very nice look to it)
Difficulty: 3 (Crop, edit, change to color tone)

Overall: 5.33

[Stereo]

Creativity: 8 (Dunno, just think its creative)
Appearance: 10 (Well done and its sexy)
Difficulty: 8 (It just looks difficult to make. >_>)

Overall: 8.666!

[Danyutz]

Creativity: 8
Appearance: 8 - a very clean look
Difficulty: 6

Overall: 7.33