Rate the signature above you!

BrontoX · Post by **BrontoX** » 12 Nov 2006, 00:07

New sig i see:
Creativity: 7
Appearance: 9
Difficulty: 9 (i think it's difficult cuz i don't know how to do it)

Overall: 8.3

korge · Post by **korge** » 12 Nov 2006, 01:12

Creativity: 5
Appearance: 7
Difficulty: 4

Simple but it looks good.

DeMyX · Post by **DeMyX** » 12 Nov 2006, 02:55

korge wrote:Creativity: 5
Appearance: 7
Difficulty: 4

Simple but it looks good.

Did you even read the rules? Only once per page.

Next person rate BrontoX

BKize_GT · Post by **BKize_GT** » 12 Nov 2006, 03:31

Creativity: 5
Appearance: 4
Difficulty: 2

Overall: 3.7

Bit too simplistic for my tastes

weedman173 · Post by **weedman173** » 12 Nov 2006, 04:50

Creativity: 7
Appearance: 8- Great brushing technique
Difficulty: 6-I have tried to make one of these kind of sigs and it looked crappy, good job

Overall: 7

I like abstract art like this.

t3ice · Post by **t3ice** » 12 Nov 2006, 13:30

@ Weedman's sig

Creativity: 8
Appearance: 6 ( maybe cuz ive seen it for too long

)
Difficulty: 8 ( if u've made ur avatar from the sig..then i can imagine ur skills

)

Overall: 7.34

Tough to make but dosent quite do the trick

_________________________________________________________________

Right...well my sig is like almost 5+ months old...AND i made it when i had no clue of photoshop....

I now realize i need a change ...but unfortunately i dont have much time these days

korge · Post by **korge** » 12 Nov 2006, 17:06

Im a person who care less for the rules but sure. Youre the boss.

t3ice wrote:@ Weedman's sig

Creativity: 8
Appearance: 6 ( maybe cuz ive seen it for too long )
Difficulty: 8 ( if u've made ur avatar from the sig..then i can imagine ur skills
)

Overall: 7.34

Tough to make but dosent quite do the trick
_________________________________________________________________

Right...well my sig is like almost 5+ months old...AND i made it when i had no clue of photoshop....

I now realize i need a change ...but unfortunately i dont have much time these days

I dont know if anyone has ever heard of Adobe Audition???

This thread lacks the background knowledge of people who actually know skill when they see it so they rate difficulty incorrectly. My sig is a rescale of a poster I made for a Support our troops program and looks spectacular but others may disagree. I think my sig looks sucks but m original print looks great.

Btw, there is nothing awesome about rendering a backing, slapping a cut and paste character on it, then adding a few bloom affects. Gaming sites are littered with them.

underoath285 · Post by **underoath285** » 13 Nov 2006, 01:22

wow i always thought weedman made that;

that changes everything....

as for korge...

Creativity - 5 (basic design)
Appearance - 8 (i like how it looks)
Difficulty - 6 (doesnt seem too hard)

Stereo · Post by **Stereo** » 13 Nov 2006, 03:57

Creativity - 7
Appearance - 6 (Needs a little work IMO... make the box some other color, not brown. >_<)
Difficulty - 7

Meh, mine probably sucks.

prince1142003 · Post by **prince1142003** » 13 Nov 2006, 03:59

Creativity - 6 (somewhat unique)
Appearance - 7 (could be better)
Difficulty - 9 (unless that background was stolen from another image)

Stereo · Post by **Stereo** » 13 Nov 2006, 04:03

The background was made up of loads of layers >_<. Manipulation x10000.
(It wasn't stolen)

prince's sig:

Creativity - 7 (Pretty cool layout but rather simple background)
Appearance - 8 (Like the cars

)
Difficulty - 5 (Cut and paste, shadows, text..)

prince1142003 · Post by **prince1142003** » 13 Nov 2006, 04:10

Simple background to accentuate the cars =D

The shadows were hand brushed. Took a while.

Stereo · Post by **Stereo** » 13 Nov 2006, 04:42

Hmm. It's an impressive job if it was handbrushed. I thought it was feathered.

prince1142003 · Post by **prince1142003** » 13 Nov 2006, 05:03

Feathering did constitute a part of it. I guess the size decrease from 1280x960 reduced quality a bit. I find that realistic shadows cannot be made by feathering alone.

Anyways, no more off topic please or else we might get banned,

.

xHaZxMaTx · Post by **xHaZxMaTx** » 13 Nov 2006, 05:07

People seem to be taking the 'Once per page' rule and beating it with a stick.

I believe the last person who was supposed to recieve critique was t3ice.

SliM_880 · Post by **SliM_880** » 13 Nov 2006, 05:31

i think we should be able to comment twice per page... once is too little...

T3ice's sig:

Creativity - 8
Appearance - 6
Difficulty - 5

Overall: 6.33

race_invader · Post by **race_invader** » 13 Nov 2006, 07:02

SliM_880

Creativity - 9

Appearance - 7

Difficulty - 10 <<< For me anyway

lol thats a sexy sig i must say

xALFAxGT · Post by **xALFAxGT** » 13 Nov 2006, 10:44

Race Invader

Creatvity - 4
Appearance - 5 (Sig slightly too small)
Difficulty - 4

Overall: 4.3333

Not a big fan of that sig - sorry man!

DeMyX · Post by **DeMyX** » 13 Nov 2006, 16:48

Creativity: 1 A bit simple to be called creative in my eyes.

Apperance: 3 A bit too simple for my taste i'm afraid. Only the unique text made it a 3

Difficulty: 2 If it wasn't for the text I would have rated it 1.

Overall: 2

korge · Post by **korge** » 13 Nov 2006, 22:22

Being a little tough there...

Creativity: 4 Can be made by anyone who follows a Photoshop signature tutorial.

Apperance: 8 Looks good, dark and evil looking.

Difficulty: 4 Just need to know how to work with layers and effects to get the same result.

BrontoX · Post by **BrontoX** » 13 Nov 2006, 22:28

Ok now you are allowed twice per page cuz even i was getting annoyed cuz it was long before a new page was made.

Creativity: 2 (i know i put a small rating when mine is even worse but i am not downvoting it's just my opinion)

Apperance: 5 can't see what is in the sig and it's small

Difficulty: 4

Overall: 3.6666 sorry mate

Jopuma · Post by **Jopuma** » 14 Nov 2006, 00:32

Creativity: 2
Appearance: 2
Difficulty: 1

Overall: 1.06

Sorry it's that low, but it's just two pictures put next to eachother on a black background with the cutout words of NFS: Carbon on the top and some standard text with a little bit of blending options.

BKize_GT · Post by **BKize_GT** » 14 Nov 2006, 00:58

Creativity - 5
Appearance - 8
Difficulty - 4

Overall - 5.7

Nice sig, but a bit simple IMHO

Jopuma · Post by **Jopuma** » 14 Nov 2006, 01:10

Creativity: 3
Appearance: 4
Difficulty: 1

Overall: 2.7 (rounded up from 2.66666667)

It's an ok sig but not that great considering it's just a white background and a red brush set downloaded from DeviantArt (that's where I got that set from anyway).

korge · Post by **korge** » 14 Nov 2006, 02:35

Oh shoot. Im sensing some tension between low votes. I feel it myself.

We all like our works of art and when someone tries to be a smart ass and says it doesnt look difficult or detailed, we get mad. I know we all do whether we post it or not...

Cmon people, be more sensisitive. In fact dont even vote on difficulty becuase you Dont know how much Actual work went into it. Keep it to Creativity or Style or Apperance if you can.